A nonprofit website isn’t just a place to explain your mission—it’s a tool to move people. Done right, it can turn curiosity into commitment. But too often, the experience feels more like wandering through a brochure than stepping into a movement. Good intentions alone don’t convert visitors into donors, volunteers, or advocates. Effective nonprofit websites aren’t just informative—they're engineered to inspire action. Here are some of the key strategies we use to transform websites for the nonprofits we work with.

Don’t design for everyone

The most common trap nonprofits fall into is trying to appeal to everyone. They often have a long list of different audiences, from small donors and major donors to policymakers or potential partners.  But when you design for everyone, you risk resonating with no one. Instead, it’s essential to identify the priority audiences: Are you trying to engage small, one-time donors? Inform institutional funders? Mobilise community volunteers? Each audience will have conflicting needs and when you need to make decisions, it’s important to know which needs should take priority.

Once you’ve defined your primary audiences, get laser-focused on what you want them to do. Whether it's signing a petition, making a donation, or simply subscribing to your newsletter—consider the key action for each audience and ensure every journey leads them there.

Build pathways, not pit stops

Imagine landing on a story that moves you—only to reach the bottom of the page and hit a dead end. No donation button. No way to get involved. Just... the footer.

Nonprofit websites should never leave visitors wondering, what now? Every journey should be designed to lead somewhere: a call to action, a deeper story, a tangible way to help. That doesn’t mean shouting donate at every turn—but it does mean being intentional. Guide people on a journey designed around their needs. Is it a news piece about community building targeted at potential volunteers? Ensure there are CTAs to join as a volunteer or links off to real stories about other volunteers. 

Inspire with real people, not just stats

Facts don’t fuel action as effectively as feelings do. And nothing moves people like real human stories. No matter if you are building homes for the unhoused or advocating for stricter digital privacy regulations, human stories are the heartbeat of any cause-driven organization. They turn abstract missions into something personal. Numbers can be important for communicating outcomes but alongside those be sure to feature names, faces, and moments of change. Let visitors see the impact through someone’s eyes—and then show them how they can be part of it.

A Digital Space Worth Believing In

Ultimately, your website isn’t just a brochure—it’s an invitation. A chance to show visitors not just what you do, but why it matters, and how they can help. The most effective nonprofit websites aren’t the ones that shout the loudest. They’re the ones that make it easy to care. Focus on the stories and the actions that matter most and build trust one person at a time. 

If you are a nonprofit that needs help turning visitors into believers, drop us a line. We would love to chat.

‍